Sarge's Delicatessen and Diner Menu
Featured Partner
548 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10016
2126790442
304 dishes
CLASSIC SANDWICHES
HOT CORNED BEEF SANDWICH
$26.95
Our homemade corned beef is cured, then boiled to perfection.
TONGUE SANDWICH
$28.95
ROAST TURKEY SANDWICH
HOT BRISKET OF BEEF SANDWICH
$26.95
ROAST BEEF SANDWICH
$26.95
Home cooked to perfection (served rare to medium rare).
TURKEY PASTRAMI SANDWICH
$24.95
ROLLED BEEF SANDWICH
$27.95
SALAMI SANDWICH
$22.95
HARD SALAMI SANDWICH
$22.95
BOILED HAM SANDWICH
$20.95
CHOPPED LIVER SANDWICH
$22.95
CHICKEN SALAD SANDWICH
$19.95
EGG SALAD SANDWICH
$17.95
TUNA SALAD SANDWICH
$18.95
WHITEFISH SALAD SANDWICH
$21.95
SANDWICH MEAT COMBO
$31.95
Choice of any two or three items.
CORNED BEEF REUBEN
$31.95
Open Faced with Swiss Cheese and Sauerkraut, Grilled To Perfection
PASTRAMI REUBEN (ROBIN)
$31.95
Pastrami, Swiss cheese and sauerkraut, grilled.
TURKEY REUBEN
$30.95
Turkey, Swiss cheese and sauerkraut, grilled.
THE HUDSON
$32.95
"Born December 12th 2018" - Open faced Pastrami & Corned Beef stacked on Rye, Swiss cheese and Sauerkraut gril…
SWEET BABY DAVES PASTRAMI
$28.95
Sweet Baby Dave's Smokehouse Pastrami Sarge's homemade pastrami topped with coleslaw and chipotle honey mustar…
SOUP | HALF SANDWICH
Choice of Bowl of Soup and Half of Our Classic Sandwich
SHRIMP SALAD SANDWICH
$21.95
LIVERWURST SANDWICH
$17.95
HOT PASTRAMI SANDWICH
$27.95
HOT SANDWICHES
THE #3
$31.95
CORNED BEEF & PASTRAMI Cole Slaw & Russian Dressing.
CHICKEN LOCO
$30.95
Chicken Cutlet, Pastrami, Melted Swiss, Coleslaw, and Russian Dressing on a Toasted Club Roll
THE SUZY GREENBERG
$27.95
Chicken Cutlet, Melted Mozzarella, Bacon and Russian Dressing on a Toasted Club Roll
BONELESS CHICKEN SANDWICH
On a Kaiser Roll (Grilled or Fried) with Lettuce & Tomato served with French Fries
FRENCH DIP SANDWICH
$31.95
Shaved Prime Roast Beef Dipped in Au Jus on a Club Roll with Horseradish Sauce and Au Jus on the side with fri…
CHICKEN PARM SANDWICH
$27.95
Fried Chicken Cutlet Topped with Melted Mozzarella Cheese and Tomato Sauce on a Toasted Garlic Club Roll
CHEESE STEAK
$31.95
Shaved Prime Roast Beef Smothered with Sautéed Onions and Peppers, Topped with Melted American Cheese on a Toa…
THE THIRD AVE
$35.95
Hot Corned Beef and Pastrami served open faced on Rye Bread with Stuffed Derma
HOT OPEN BRISKET
$30.95
with French Fries and Gravy
HOT OPEN ROAST BEEF
$30.95
with French Fries and Gravy
HOT OPEN TURKEY
$30.95
with French Fries and Gravy
NOSHES | FRANKS | APPS
STUFFED KNISH
Square potato knish stuffed with a hot dog, corned beef or pastrami topped with mustard or Russian, grilled ad…
FRANK ON A BUN SNAP O RAZZO
$7.95
Served on a Bun with Sauerkraut or Red Onions
GRILLED KNOCKWURST
$9.95
Grilled Knockwurst served on a bun
POTATO PANCAKE (1)
$6.95
CHOPPED LIVER (APP)
$14.95
STUFFED DERMA
$16.95
Our kishka is famous (watch the 3rd episode of season one of "The Deuce" on HBO. A scene in this episode was f…
STUFFED CABBAGE
$16.95
FRIED KREPLACH
$14.95
With fried onions
CHICKEN FINGERS
$16.95
GEFILTE FISH
$10.95
BUFFALO WINGS
$21.95
KNISH SQUARE (FRIED)
$7.95
KNISH ROUND (BAKED)
$7.95
JEWISH DAIRY SPECIALS
CHEESE BLINTZES -S
$23.95
Three blintzes served with complimentary Sour Cream
POTATO PANCAKES (3) -S
$18.95
Three pancakes served with sour cream or applesauce.
NOODLE KUGEL -S
$13.95
Serves 2
MATZO BRIE -S
$18.95
with Apple Sauce
SIDES
FRENCH FRIES (SIDE)
$9.95
SWEET POTATO FRIES (SIDE)
$10.95
POTATO SALAD (SIDE)
$6.95
COLESLAW (SIDE)
$6.95
MACARONI SALAD (SIDE)
$6.95
OLD FASHIONED ONION RINGS (SIDE)
$12.95
KASHA VARNISHKAS (SIDE)
$11.95
EGG BARLEY | MUSHROOMS (SIDE)
$11.95
FRIED MUSHROOMS | ONIONS (SIDE)
$8.95
CORNED BEEF HASH (SIDE)
$17.95
BACON (SIDE)
$8.95
BREAKFAST SAUSAGE (SIDE)
$8.95
BAKED BEANS (SIDE)
$9.95
TOSSED GREEN SALAD (SIDE)
$9.95
SWEET PEPPERS (SIDE)
$7.95
HOT PEPPERS (SIDE)
$7.95
SAUERKRAUT (SIDE)
$5.95
PICKLED TOMATOES (SIDE)
$7.95
STUFFING (SIDE)
$8.95
FRUIT SALAD (SIDE)
$7.95
TOMATO (SIDE)
$2.95
AVOCADO (SIDE)
$4.95
APPLESAUCE (SIDE)
$5.95
EXTRA SAUCES | PICKLES (SIDE)
ALL DAY BREAKFAST
THREE EGGS ANY STYLE
$15.95
Three eggs any style with toast and fries or homefries
GARDEN OMELETTE
$21.95
Tomato, Onions, Mushrooms, Broccoli
WESTERN OMELETTE
$19.95
Ham, Peppers, Onion
CHEESE OMELETTE
$19.95
Choice of American, Swiss or Cheddar
DELICATESSEN OMELETTE
$29.95
Corned Beef, Pastrami, Tonuge, Salami
MYO OMELETTE
$15.95
FROM THE GRIDDLE
CHALLAH FRENCH TOAST
$16.95
dipped in Egg Batter and grilled to a golden brown
STACK OF PANCAKES
$16.95
Chocolate Chip or Blueberry
BAGELS | TOAST
BAGEL
$3.95
ROLL
$3.95
ENGLISH MUFFIN
$3.95
TOAST
$2.95
CRAVING SOMETHING DIFFERENT?
CHICKEN POT PIE
$20.95
Blend of chicken, peas, carrots, onions, potatoes and fresh cream in a pie shell pastry.
MEAT EGG AND CHEESE
$10.95
Bacon, Ham or Sausage served with 2 eggs on a roll
GRILLED CHEESE
$10.95
BLT ON TOAST
$15.95
Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato
TUNA MELT
$25.95
With Tomato and American Cheese on Grilled Rye
SARGES FAVORITE
$30.95
Hot Brisket on Potato Pancake with Gravy and Applesauce
2 EGGS ON A ROLL
$7.95
2 eggs on a roll
TURKEY CLUB
$27.95
Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato on white toast with Mayo
CHICKEN SALAD CLUB
$27.95
Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato on white toast with Mayo
DELI MEAT (LB)
BEEF FRANKS (LB)
$24.00
BEEF KNOCKWURST (LB)
$26.00
BEEF SALAMI (LB)
$24.00
BOILED HAM (LB)
$18.00
FRESH ROASTED TURKEY (LB)
$34.00
HARD SALAMI (LB)
$30.00
LIVERWURST (LB)
$16.00
ROAST BEEF (LB)
$38.00
ROLLED BEEF (LB)
$42.00
TONGUE (LB)
$44.00
TURKEY PASTRAMI (LB)
$32.00
UNREAL CORNED BEEF (LB)
$21.00
UNREAL TURKEY (LB)
$21.00
ROAST CHICKEN
GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST
$8.95
FRIED CHICKEN BREAST CUTLET
$8.95
CORNED BEEF (LB)
PASTRAMI (LB)
BRISKET (LB)
SMOKED FISH
NOVA SCOTIA
$22.95
NOVA SPECIAL (FOR 2)
$39.95
Two bagels, extra Nova Scotia cured salmon, cream cheese, onion, tomato
SMOKED WHITEFISH
$22.95
Served with bagel, choice of cream cheese, onion, tomato
HERRING
PICKLED HERRING (ONIONS)
$12.95
With marinated onions
PICKLED HERRING (CREAM SAUCE)
$12.95
With marinated onions
DELI CHEESE (LB)
CHEDDAR CHEESE (LB)
$16.00
AMERICAN CHEESE (LB)
$12.00
MOZZARELLA CHEESE (LB)
$16.00
MUENSTER CHEESE (LB)
$16.00
PLAIN CREAM CHEESE (LB)
$14.00
SCALLION CREAM CHEESE (LB)
$16.00
VEGETABLE CREAM CHEESE (LB)
$16.00
SWISS CHEESE (LB)
$16.00
PROVOLONE CHEESE (LB)
$16.00
CAKES
APPLE STRUDEL
$11.95
CARROT CAKE
$10.95
CHOCOLATE CHIP FUDGE CAKE
$10.95
SEVEN LAYER CAKE
$10.95
COCONUT SNOWBALL
$10.95
GERMAN CHOCOLATE
$10.95
BLACK AND WHITE MOUSSE SUPREME
$10.95
HOMEMADE CHEESECAKES
ORIGINAL NEW YORK CHEESECAKE
$10.95
STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE
$12.95
PEANUT BUTTER CHOC CHIP CHEESECA
$12.95
PIES
A LA MODE
$3.00
KEY LIME PIE
$7.95
APPLE PIE
$9.95
BANANA CREAM PIE
$9.95
PECAN PIE
$9.95
PUMPKIN PIE (SEASONAL)
$9.95
COOKIES | ICE CREAM
LARGE BLACK AND WHITE COOKIE
$4.95
LARGE CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
$4.95
FRENCH ICE CREAM
RUGGELACH (6)
$8.95
MARBLE NUT HALVAH
$9.95
RICE PUDDING
$7.95
FRUIT JELLO
$7.95
SALAD PLATTERS
SALAD PLATTER
SMOKED WHITEFISH SALAD PLATTER
$26.95
SHRIMP SALAD PLATTER
$26.95
COLD CUT PLATTERS
ASSRTD COLD CUTS ALA SARGE
$41.95
Choice of any 4 Meats or Cheese, with Cole Slaw & Potato Salad (Enough for 2)
HOT CORNED BEEF PLATTER
$32.95
Thinly Sliced & Delicious, Served with Potato Salad & Cole Slaw
HOT PASTRAMI PLATTER
$34.95
Served With Potato Salad & Cole Slaw
COMBO HOT CB & PASTRAMI
$35.95
TONGUE PLATTER
$36.95
Served with Potato Salad & Cole Slaw
HOT BRISKET PLATTER
$32.95
DELI DRINKS
DR BROWNS
$3.95
FOUNTAIN SODA
$3.25
CAN SODA
$3.50
LEGENDARY EGG CREAM
MILKSHAKE (EXTRA THICK)
COLUMBIAN COFFEE
$3.50
HOT TEA
$3.50
JUICE
$4.95
ORANGE JUICE
$5.95
ICED TEA
$4.95
ANDYS 18TH HOLE
$5.95
80% Iced Tea, 20% Lemonade, 100% refreshing
BOTTLE OF WATER
$2.50
ICED COFFEE
$4.95
BURGERS
BEEF BURGER
$19.95
SKYSCRAPER
Choice of Corned Beef or Pastrami and Melted American Cheese
PATTY MELT
$21.95
On Grilled Rye, With Sautéed Onions and Melted American Cheese
SLIDERS
$19.95
Four Mini Burgers with Grilled Onions and Melted American Cheese
COOKOUT BURGER
$24.95
Smokey BBQ Sauce, Melted Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Sauteéd Mushrooms, and Onions
VEGGIE BURGER
$16.95
CHEESEBURGER
$21.95
SALADS
CAESAR SALAD
$19.95
With Romaine, Croutons, Grated Parmesan and Creamy Caesar
CHOPPED SALAD
$21.95
With Iceberg, Romain, Radicchio, Cucumber, Tomato, Green Onions, Chick Peas and Roasted Corn
COBB SALAD
$25.95
Grilled Chicken Breast, Avocado, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Bacon, Sliced Egg and Tomatoes on Mixed Greens
CHEFS SALAD
$26.95
Fresh Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, Swiss, and Tomatoes on Mixed Greens
ENTREES
CHICKEN IN THE POT
$33.95
With Matzo Ball, Noodles, Peas and Carrots
POT ROAST
$33.95
Served with Choice of Potato and Vegetable
HALF ROAST CHICKEN
$33.95
with Stuffing
ROAST TURKEY
$33.95
All White, Dark or Mixed Meat with Stuffing and Gravy, Choice of Potato and Vegetable
CORNED BEEF AND CABBAGE
$35.95
With Boiled Potatoes
"SPECIALS"
Grilled or Boiled Knockwursts with Sauerkraut, Baked Beans and French Fries
BROILED SALMON
$34.95
Choice of Potato and Vegetable
POTATOES | VEGETABLES
FRENCH FRIES
$9.95
BAKED YAM
$8.95
BAKED POTATO
$7.95
MASHED POTATO
$7.95
BOILED POTATO
$7.95
HOME FRIES
$8.95
SWEET POTATO FRIES
$10.95
CANDIED SWEETS
$8.95
CORN ON THE COB
$7.95
FRESH BROCCOLI
$7.95
SLICED CARROTS
$7.95
STRING BEANS
$7.95
SWEET PEAS
$7.95
CREAMED SPINACH
$9.95
PEAS AND CARROTS
$7.95
UNREAL DELI
UNREAL TURKEY SANDWICH
$18.95
100% Plant Based
UNREAL CORNED BEEF SANDWICH
$18.95
100% Plant Based
UNREAL TURKEY REUBEN
$22.95
100% Plant Based
UNREAL CORNED BEEF REUBEN
$22.95
100% Plant Based
MERCH
T-SHIRT
$29.95
MONSTER MUG
$15.00
SOUP MUG
$25.00
PASTRAMI HAT
$45.00
DELI ITEMS
MUSTARD
RUSSIAN
MAYO
SINGLE BAGEL
$1.50
SINGLE ROLL
$1.50
MATZO (SLICE)
$0.75
PLAIN CREAM CHEESE (LB)
$14.00
SCALLION CREAM CHEESE (LB)
$16.00
VEG CREAM CHEESE (LB)
$16.00
CHICKEN SALAD (LB)
$20.00
CHOPPED CHICKEN LIVER (LB)
$22.00
COLE SLAW (LB)
$12.00
COTTAGE CHEESE
$6.95
CRANBERRY SAUCE
$5.95
EGG BARLEY | MUSHROOMS (LB)
$10.00
EGG SALAD (LB)
$18.00
GRAVY
$5.95
GRAVY ON SIDE (.25 OZ)
HERRING FILET
$6.00
KASHA VARNISHKAS (LB)
$10.00
HERRING | CREAM SAUCE (LB)
$20.00
MACARONI SALAD (LB)
$12.00
NOVA SALMON (LB)
$60.00
POTATO SALAD (LB)
$12.00
SHRIMP SALAD (LB)
$28.00
TUNA SALAD (LB)
$20.00
WHITEFISH SALAD (LB)
$32.00
OLIVES
$6.95
PICKLES (QUART)
$10.00
RUGGELACH (LB)
$18.00
MUSTARD (1/2LB)
$4.00
RUSSIAN (1/2LB)
$4.00
GEFILTE FISH
$5.00
CHALLAH BREAD
RYE BREAD
PICKLE
DELI ITEMS (1/4 LB)
HERRING | CREAM SAUCE (1/4LB)
$5.00
SCALLION CREAM CHEESE (1/4LB)
$4.00
PLAIN CREAM CHEESE (1/4LB)
$3.50
VEG CREAM CHEESE (1/4LB)
$4.00
CHICKEN SALAD (1/4LB)
$4.75
CHOPPED CHICKEN LIVER (1/4LB)
$4.50
COLE SLAW (1/4LB)
$3.00
MACARONI SALAD (1/4LB)
$3.00
EGG BARLEY | MUSHROOMS (1/4LB)
$2.50
EGG SALAD (1/4LB)
$4.50
KASHA VARNISHKAS (1/4LB)
$2.50
NOVA SALMON (1/4LB)
$15.00
POTATO SALAD (1/4LB)
$3.00
TUNA SALAD (1/4LB)
$5.00
WHITEFISH SALAD (1/4LB)
$8.00
SHRIMP SALAD (1/4LB)
$7.00
RUGGELACH (1/4LB)
$4.50
DELI ITEMS (1/2 LB)
HERRING | CREAM SAUCE (1/2LB)
$5.00
SCALLION CREAM CHEESE (1/2LB)
$8.00
PLAIN CREAM CHEESE (1/2LB)
$7.00
VEG CREAM CHEESE (1/2LB)
$8.00
CHICKEN SALAD (1/2LB)
$9.50
CHOPPED CHICKEN LIVER (1/2LB)
$9.00
COLE SLAW (1/2LB)
$6.00
MACARONI SALAD (1/2LB)
$3.00
EGG BARLEY | MUSHROOMS (1/2LB)
$5.00
EGG SALAD (1/2LB)
$9.00
KASHA VARNISHKAS (1/2LB)
$5.00
NOVA SALMON (1/2LB)
$30.00
POTATO SALAD (1/2LB)
$6.00
TUNA SALAD (1/2LB)
$10.00
WHITEFISH SALAD (1/2LB)
$8.00
SHRIMP SALAD (1/2LB)
$14.00
RUGGELACH (1/2LB)
$8.96
DELI SOUPS
OLD FASHIONED CHICKEN CONSOMME
$7.95
With Matzo Ball, Kreplach, Rice or Noodles
MATZO BALL SOUP
$9.95
Chicken consomme with 1 matzo ball. Freshly made every day, enjoy it plain or add in one or more of our soup e…
MATZO NOODLE SOUP
$9.95
Chicken consomme with 1 matzo ball and noodles. Freshly made every day, enjoy it plain or add in one or more o…
KREPLACH SOUP
$9.95
NOODLE SOUP
$9.95
RICE SOUP
$9.95
SOUPER SOUP
$14.95
With Matzo Ball, Kreplach & Noodles
MUSHROOM BARLEY SOUP
$9.95
VEGETABLE SOUP
$9.95
Homemade vegetable soup with seasonal vegetables.
SPLIT PEA SOUP
$9.95
Served with homemade croutons on the side.
BORSCHT
$9.95
with sour cream
FRENCH ONION
$11.95
DRY MATZO BALL
$3.95
DRY KREPLACH
$3.95
DRY NOODLES
$3.95
MATZOBALL SOUP FOR 2
$28.95
64 oz. consommé with 2 Matzo Balls
KREPLACH SOUP FOR 2
$28.95
64 oz. consommé with 2 Kreplach